Files
manifoldbt/.github/workflows/bench-vs-vectorbt.yml
T
Exocet92andGitHub 6cae686283 bench: add a cost workload and a multi-asset one, and go to three repetitions (#10)
Two gaps a reader could name without running anything: costs appeared on one
workload out of four, and nothing in the suite was a portfolio.

Costs could not simply be switched on across the board, and the reason is
measured. On FractionOfEquity sizing a 5 bps fee puts the engines 1.3e-4 of
capital apart and 2 bps of slippage 2.1e-5, against a 1e-9 tolerance, while the
round-trip counts stay identical: the trading agrees, the cost arithmetic does
not, because one charges the fee on top of the notional and the other reserves
it out of cash first. In fixed units both land exactly, to 1e-15. So
`sma_cross_costs` carries a fee and slippage on the headline signal, sized in
units, and the price of that is visible rather than hidden: x48.0 against x50.6
at 100k bars.

`multi_asset` runs five independent series in one shared book. It is the
workload manifoldbt does worst on, and it is here for that reason: going from
one asset to five costs it 6.1x and vectorbt 1.4x, so the ratio falls from x36.7
to x8.8 at a million bars. Broadcasting a column per asset is close to free;
walking five books is not. A portfolio is also what people actually run, and a
suite that only measures where it wins is not evidence.

Both are capped where a materialised five-column simulation would stop measuring
the engine and start measuring the swap file, and `ema_rsi_fees` keeps the
ceiling it got for going bankrupt.

Repetitions go from two to three: the floor at which a median is a median rather
than the mean of two.
2026-08-20 18:45:05 +02:00

230 lines
9.9 KiB
YAML

# The benchmark runs here, in the open, on standard GitHub-hosted runners.
#
# Nothing in this workflow has access to the engine source: it installs the
# published wheel from PyPI, exactly like any user would. That is what makes the
# result independent rather than self-reported, and it is why anyone can fork
# this repository and press "Run workflow" to reproduce the numbers on their own
# runner. Same for the engines it is compared against: they come from PyPI at
# pinned versions, and the run prints the versions it resolved.
name: Benchmark vs vectorbt and raptorbt
on:
workflow_dispatch:
inputs:
manifoldbt_version:
description: "manifoldbt version to install from PyPI (blank = latest)"
required: false
default: ""
reps:
description: "Interleaved repetitions per point"
required: false
# 3, not 7. The budget went into a longer series and two more
# workloads instead: at 10M bars one vectorbt call costs 99 s, so seven
# of them would put the job past its timeout. Three is the floor at
# which a median is a median rather than the mean of two, though an
# interquartile range still wants four samples to mean anything, so the
# noise flag stays coarse. A point that looks surprising is worth
# re-running at a higher `reps` before it is quoted anywhere.
default: "3"
release:
types: [published]
schedule:
# Weekly, to catch a slowdown introduced by a dependency rather than by us.
- cron: "17 5 * * 1"
permissions:
contents: read
concurrency:
group: bench-vs-vectorbt-${{ github.ref }}
cancel-in-progress: true
jobs:
bench:
# Named for what the job measures, not for the runner it landed on. The
# runner is already on the row; what a reader needs from the job list is
# which half of the benchmark it is.
name: backtests (${{ matrix.os }})
runs-on: ${{ matrix.os }}
# A published release is not always a released version. The preview tags
# 0.18.0rc1 and rc2 went to the public repository without ever reaching
# PyPI, so `pip install manifoldbt==0.18.0rc2` failed and this workflow went
# red four times in two days for a reason that had nothing to do with any
# engine. Pre-releases are skipped; a manual dispatch can still benchmark
# one by naming the version, if it ever exists on PyPI.
if: github.event_name != 'release' || github.event.release.prerelease == false
timeout-minutes: 60
strategy:
fail-fast: false
matrix:
include:
# Linux only, on purpose. The other two runners were carried for a
# reason that does not survive examination: they were the only place
# anything installed the published wheel on Windows or macOS, which
# made this benchmark a smoke test by accident. That check is worth
# having and worth 40 seconds next to the build in release.yml, not 13
# minutes inside a performance measurement, and nobody reads a
# benchmark to find out whether a package imports.
#
# What is lost is a per-platform timing, which was never quoted: the
# numbers that get published are the Linux ones. Adding a platform
# back is one entry here.
- os: ubuntu-latest
bars: "100000 1000000 10000000"
env:
PYTHONUNBUFFERED: "1"
steps:
- uses: actions/checkout@v4
- uses: actions/setup-python@v5
with:
# 3.12, not 3.13, and it is raptorbt that pins it: it is built against
# pyo3 0.20.3, whose maximum supported CPython is 3.12. No release up
# to 0.9.0 publishes a cp313 wheel and a source build refuses outright
# ("the configured Python interpreter version (3.13) is newer than
# PyO3's maximum supported version (3.12)"). Comparing engines means
# running them in one environment, and the environment has to be one
# they all support. Runs before 2026-08-20 used 3.13 with two engines,
# so their absolute timings are not directly comparable with these.
python-version: "3.12"
- name: Install engines from PyPI
shell: bash
run: |
set -e
VERSION="${{ inputs.manifoldbt_version }}"
# A release run benchmarks the version that was just published.
if [ -z "$VERSION" ] && [ "${{ github.event_name }}" = "release" ]; then
VERSION="$(echo '${{ github.event.release.tag_name }}' | sed 's/^v//')"
fi
python -m pip install --upgrade pip
if [ -n "$VERSION" ]; then
pip install "manifoldbt==${VERSION}"
else
pip install manifoldbt
fi
pip install -r benchmarks/vs_vectorbt/requirements-lock.txt
- name: Record the resolved environment
shell: bash
run: pip freeze | grep -iE '^(manifoldbt|vectorbt|raptorbt|numpy|numba|pandas|psutil)=' || true
- name: Run the benchmark
shell: bash
working-directory: benchmarks/vs_vectorbt
run: |
python bench.py \
--bars ${{ matrix.bars }} \
--reps "${{ inputs.reps || '7' }}" \
--cold-start-reps 3 \
--memory-bars 2000000 \
--out "results-${{ matrix.os }}.json"
- name: Render the report
# Runs even when the benchmark exits non-zero: a parity failure is the
# most interesting thing that can happen here, and it must be readable
# in the job summary rather than buried in a red step. But only if there
# is something to render: when the install step failed, this used to die
# on a missing file and put a FileNotFoundError on top of the real
# error, which is how a run reports the wrong cause twice.
if: always()
shell: bash
working-directory: benchmarks/vs_vectorbt
run: |
if [ -f "results-${{ matrix.os }}.json" ]; then
python report.py "results-${{ matrix.os }}.json"
else
echo "no result file: the benchmark did not get far enough to write one"
fi
- name: Upload the raw result
if: always()
uses: actions/upload-artifact@v4
with:
name: bench-${{ matrix.os }}
path: benchmarks/vs_vectorbt/results-*.json
if-no-files-found: warn
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------ #
# Parameter sweeps, which need a licence and therefore a job of their own
# ------------------------------------------------------------------------ #
sweeps:
name: sweeps (ubuntu-latest)
runs-on: ubuntu-latest
if: github.event_name != 'release' || github.event.release.prerelease == false
timeout-minutes: 45
steps:
- uses: actions/checkout@v4
- uses: actions/setup-python@v5
with:
python-version: "3.12"
- name: Install engines from PyPI
shell: bash
run: |
set -e
VERSION="${{ inputs.manifoldbt_version }}"
if [ -z "$VERSION" ] && [ "${{ github.event_name }}" = "release" ]; then
VERSION="$(echo '${{ github.event.release.tag_name }}' | sed 's/^v//')"
fi
python -m pip install --upgrade pip
if [ -n "$VERSION" ]; then pip install "manifoldbt==${VERSION}"; else pip install manifoldbt; fi
pip install -r benchmarks/vs_vectorbt/requirements-lock.txt
# A sweep benchmark without a licence does not fail, it produces a wrong
# number: every unlicensed fan-out call waits a fixed interval before any
# work starts, so the stopwatch would time the wait. This step exits
# non-zero rather than let that happen, and the harness refuses again on
# its own if the tier is not what it expects.
- name: Activate the benchmark licence
env:
MANIFOLDBT_CI_LICENSE: ${{ secrets.MANIFOLDBT_CI_LICENSE }}
shell: bash
working-directory: benchmarks/vs_vectorbt
run: python ci_activate.py
- name: Run the sweeps
shell: bash
working-directory: benchmarks/vs_vectorbt
# Three points, sized from what this runner actually did rather than
# guessed. Measured here: 87.5 us per combination for manifoldbt at
# 20,000 bars, 1.16 ms for vectorbt, 1.34 ms for raptorbt, and 15.0 ms
# for raptorbt at 200,000 bars.
#
# The first point is the only one vectorbt can hold: at 20,000 bars it
# materialises 1.57 MB per combination, so 5,000 of them already cost it
# 2.5 GB and 20,000 would need 31 GB. The other two are out of its
# scope, and they are where a sweep stops being a speed comparison and
# becomes a capability one.
#
# raptorbt sets the budget, not manifoldbt: with no fan-out API its
# sweep is a Python loop, so it costs a full backtest per cell. That is
# why the large point goes deep in combinations on short series rather
# than the reverse -- 20,000 combinations on 20,000 bars costs it 27 s a
# call, where 5,000 combinations on a million bars would cost it 25 min.
run: |
python bench.py --workloads sma_cross --bars 100000 --reps 1 --cold-start-reps 0 --sweep 20000:5000 20000:20000:oos 200000:10000:oos --sweep-reps "${{ inputs.reps || '2' }}" --out "results-sweeps.json"
- name: Render the report
if: always()
shell: bash
working-directory: benchmarks/vs_vectorbt
run: |
if [ -f results-sweeps.json ]; then
python report.py results-sweeps.json
else
echo "no result file: the grids did not get far enough to write one"
fi
- name: Upload the raw result
if: always()
uses: actions/upload-artifact@v4
with:
name: bench-sweeps
path: benchmarks/vs_vectorbt/results-sweeps.json
if-no-files-found: warn