Files
fx-quant/results/phase1/S19_GBP_USD_test_set_trades.csv
Brent NealeandClaude Opus 4.6 17b80b7d17 Add 5 new ranging strategies (S17-S21) — all tested, none show edge
Implemented and backtested 5 ranging-market M15 strategies across
3 periods (Training 2021-2023, Test Set 2023-2024, 2025) and 4 pairs
(EUR_USD, GBP_USD, GBP_JPY, GBP_AUD). All 5 fail Phase 1 validation:

- S17 BB Rejection: PF 0.55-0.92, -1208p on 2025 (347 trades)
- S18 Failed Breakout: PF 0.53-0.84, -1905p on 2025 (747 trades)
- S19 VWAP Deviation: PF 0.23-1.65, -87p on 2025 (37 trades)
- S20 Range Compression: only 5 trades on 2025 (too restrictive)
- S21 EMA Ribbon Bounce: PF 0.64-0.89, -3358p on 2025 (1088 trades)

Also added midnight-reset VWAP indicator and downloaded 2025 M15 data
for EUR_USD, GBP_JPY, GBP_AUD.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-02-21 20:48:03 +10:00

6.0 KiB

1timestampstrategy_idpairsignal_directionentry_pricesl_pricetp1_pricetp2_pricetp3_pricelot_sizeconfluence_scoresessionspread_at_entryatr_at_entryadx_at_entryrsi_at_entryema_50_valueema_200_valuevwap_deviationnews_within_60minmacd_hist_at_entrystoch_k_at_entrydistance_from_ema50_pipscandle_body_ratiohour_of_dayday_of_weekentry_patternexit_priceexit_reasonexit_timepnl_pipspnl_dollarshold_time_minuteswin
22023-11-06 06:30:00+00:0019GBP_USDSHORT1.238231.23875923662070231.2372702696133131.2372702696133131.2372702696133131889513.992ASIAN1.50.00049632233579641823.76726611321114369.230423771282691.23624114181367921.227684436117285255.29477918618131False5.578892332675861e-0577.0050130738190722.388581863208580.629629629629660160vwap_deviation_mr_short1.2387592366207023SL2023-11-06 06:45:00+00:00-5.292366207023668-999.999998837445815False
32023-11-29 09:15:00+00:0019GBP_USDLONG1.268651.26834226580250481.2709674974633051.2709674974633051.2709674974633053217062.024LONDON1.50.000875077220266711622.96409057807323333.733655656995911.27007426834414621.2658558571347693-14.159800396749134False-0.0002315128194129609512.408124494495567-16.1426834414624130.588709677419494992vwap_deviation_mr_long1.2683422658025048SL2023-11-29 09:30:00+00:00-3.0773419749530184-989.999999017314715False
42024-02-14 06:00:00+00:0019GBP_USDSHORT1.26051.26110122546678331.25967853012025781.25967853012025781.25967853012025781630170.474ASIAN1.50.0004742317821751373623.9703765040030564.622984766436131.25993017114923541.2612968281694552-1.806111205280292False8.342533364435182e-0572.152434124265048.1982885076459230.796875000000048762vwap_deviation_mr_short1.2596785301202578TP32024-02-14 07:00:00+00:008.2146988478135261339.135948164863360True
52024-05-23 11:45:00+00:0019GBP_USDSHORT1.273821.2744928919374871.2724315480262551.2724315480262551.2724315480262551476450.093LONDON1.50.000687114637077361518.64418171398429564.231090661711261.27248944148606721.271927457195921415.492368795553269False0.000164852489840237987.7711803880267815.205585139328460.8315789473686819113vwap_deviation_mr_short1.274492891937487SL2024-05-23 13:15:00+00:00-6.728919374869857-993.491361662934590False
62024-07-03 05:15:00+00:0019GBP_USDLONG1.268171.26772455923399231.26858586869035661.26858586869035661.26858586869035662208052.163ASIAN1.50.00028710315212144523.9914121731798235.895192074063471.26813947429001581.266361518410115611.52418598651117False-8.3634389486624e-0517.82731861255577-2.19474290015897470.666666666667115352vwap_deviation_mr_long1.2685858686903566TP32024-07-03 06:45:00+00:004.158686922400099918.259764176929390True
72024-07-16 12:15:00+00:0019GBP_USDSHORT1.297641.29796325438806971.29635920491626131.29635920491626131.29635920491626133071076.773LONDON1.50.000534683157269437621.1643431311672968.438632085023071.29653935678709151.295765940305382312.687983034460615False0.0001113529612061561992.3617123617089712.9064321290850440.8314606741574155121vwap_deviation_mr_short1.2963592049162613TP32024-07-16 12:30:00+00:0012.807950879090813933.42004160768715True
82024-07-24 11:30:00+00:0019GBP_USDSHORT1.29091999999999981.2913008002166121.28941365273671281.28941365273671281.28941365273671282710274.833LONDON1.50.00062904915996636224.45123652326036365.553623154045161.2897902853382611.29100966706614813.990521987732318False0.0001695575624668227781.1901532240445813.1971466173896880.6779661016947367112vwap_deviation_mr_short1.291300800216612SL2024-07-24 11:45:00+00:00-3.8080021661213155-1032.07324234240815False
92024-08-13 03:30:00+00:0019GBP_USDSHORT1.277381.27790897526587881.27690960004782841.27690960004782841.27690960004782841931569.542ASIAN1.50.000333125072683455220.81831167420936567.480713052826081.27680179807100851.2757892901888518.639808992227938False7.30643802656501e-0584.125990821871928.2820192899157870.909090909090970231vwap_deviation_mr_short1.2779089752658788SL2024-08-13 05:00:00+00:00-5.289752658788061-1021.752510984903190False
102024-11-01 09:00:00+00:0019GBP_USDSHORT1.29115999999999991.29191549680837281.28953745765882431.28953745765882431.28953745765882431338900.413LONDON1.50.00079267971651616313.83073484732004165.358460445527441.28999018870470381.2931707830717237.441487915318401False0.0001702069891898131867.222222222220813.598112952961650.859813084112256294vwap_deviation_mr_short1.2919154968083728SL2024-11-01 11:45:00+00:00-7.554968083729463-1011.5349864842292165False
112024-12-06 12:00:00+00:0019GBP_USDSHORT1.27700999999999981.2774327751698051.27530010414734151.27530010414734151.27530010414734152368681.293LONDON1.50.000710890340821111919.67934749726992366.342308846909531.2755140985039981.27302383141402129.76398140978496False9.367269981038986e-0581.7393669809196816.859014960017850.27419354838681376124vwap_deviation_mr_short1.277432775169805SL2024-12-06 12:15:00+00:00-4.227751698051563-1001.419634594046715False
122024-12-10 06:00:00+00:0019GBP_USDSHORT1.27556999999999991.27620794660699181.27467017949082551.27467017949082551.27467017949082551554057.082ASIAN1.50.000512589038722055721.407043396715264.459961282100381.27512502526748481.274847198415795-6.099157136882916False0.0001505418519547143283.256959461775376.949747325151190.785714285714427461vwap_deviation_mr_short1.2762079466069918SL2024-12-10 06:15:00+00:00-6.379466069919015-991.405441257742215False
132024-12-17 12:45:00+00:0019GBP_USDSHORT1.270431.27132719650855531.26889912202869741.26889912202869741.26889912202869741093953.642LONDON1.50.000809358159952636924.70781904372659566.33869764429731.26887407715751271.267587642578844414.274817340009793False0.0001491752808157615276.6402470207973317.459228424874240.2037037037038103121vwap_deviation_mr_short1.2688991220286974TP32024-12-17 14:30:00+00:0015.3087798529657281674.7095444110523105True