5 major issues reflected in documentation: 1. Confidence calibration (03-SMC, 00-ARSITEKTUR): - Base 55% + 10% each → base 40% + weighted scoring - Structure +15%, BOS/CHoCH +12%, FVG +8%, OB +10%, Trend +10% 2. ATR-based pullback filter (09-Entry, 00-ARSITEKTUR): - Hardcoded $2/$1.5 → bounce 15% ATR, consolidation 10% ATR 3. Smarter time-based exit (10-Exit, 05-Risk, 00-ARSITEKTUR): - 4h: check profit growth, not just profit<$5 - 6h: extend to 8h if profit>$10 and growing + ML agrees 4. Slippage validation (09-Entry, 23-Main, 00-ARSITEKTUR): - Check actual vs expected price, log if >0.15% 5. Partial fill handling (09-Entry, 23-Main, 00-ARSITEKTUR): - Check filled volume, use actual values for tracking Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
8.8 KiB
8.8 KiB
Exit Trade — Proses Keluar Posisi
File utama:
main_live.py,src/smart_risk_manager.pyFile pendukung:src/position_manager.py
Apa Itu Exit Trade?
Exit Trade adalah keseluruhan proses monitoring posisi terbuka dan memutuskan kapan menutup. Bot memeriksa setiap posisi terbuka setiap ~10 detik (di antara candle) atau setiap candle baru (full analysis) dengan 10 kondisi exit berbeda.
Analogi: Exit Trade seperti pilot otomatis di pesawat — terus monitor ketinggian (profit), cuaca (momentum), bahan bakar (waktu), dan bisa landing darurat kapan saja.
2 Jalur Exit
Jalur 1: BROKER EXIT (otomatis, independen)
-> Harga hit TP level -> tutup otomatis
-> Harga hit SL level -> tutup otomatis
-> Tidak perlu bot online
Jalur 2: SOFTWARE EXIT (cerdas, kontekstual)
-> Bot evaluasi setiap 1 detik
-> Mempertimbangkan momentum, ML, waktu, dll
-> 10 kondisi exit berbeda
Monitoring Loop
# main_live.py Lines 1117-1215
# Setiap 1 detik, untuk SETIAP posisi terbuka:
for position in open_positions:
# Update data posisi
current_price = mt5.get_tick(symbol)
current_profit = position.profit
# Update history untuk analisis momentum
guard.update_history(current_price, current_profit, ml_confidence)
# Evaluasi: haruskah ditutup?
should_close, reason, message = smart_risk.evaluate_position(
ticket=ticket,
current_price=current_price,
current_profit=profit,
ml_signal=ml_prediction.signal,
ml_confidence=ml_prediction.confidence,
regime=regime_state,
)
if should_close:
# Tutup posisi
close_position(ticket, reason)
10 Kondisi Exit (Urutan Pengecekan)
CHECK 1: Smart Take Profit (profit >= $15)
Ketika profit sudah cukup besar, evaluasi apakah harus diamankan:
a) Hard TP: profit >= $40
-> TUTUP langsung, target tercapai
b) Momentum TP: profit >= $25 DAN momentum < -30
-> TUTUP, profit sedang turun cepat
c) Peak Protection: peak > $30 DAN current < 60% peak
-> TUTUP, lindungi dari drawback lebih dalam
d) Probability TP: TP_prob < 25% DAN profit >= $20
-> TUTUP, kemungkinan capai TP sudah rendah
e) Strong Momentum: momentum >= 0
-> HOLD, biarkan profit berjalan (let it run)
CHECK 2: Early Exit Small Profit ($5-$15)
Profit masih kecil tapi ada tanda bahaya:
IF profit $5-$15
AND momentum < -50 (turun sangat cepat)
AND ML confidence >= 65% berlawanan arah:
-> TUTUP, ambil profit kecil sebelum hilang
CHECK 3: Early Cut (v4 — Smart Hold DIHAPUS)
Posisi sedang rugi — potong cepat jika sinyal buruk:
IF profit < 0:
Loss >= 30% max ($15 dari $50) DAN momentum < -30
-> TUTUP CEPAT (early cut, jangan tunggu recovery)
v4 PERUBAHAN: "Smart Hold" DIHAPUS
- SEBELUMNYA: Hold posisi rugi menunggu golden time (20:00-23:59)
- SEBELUMNYA: Hold posisi rugi kecil di sesi London (15:00-19:00)
- SEKARANG: Tidak ada lagi "hold losers hoping for recovery"
- ALASAN: Menahan posisi rugi menunggu sesi tertentu = perilaku
berbahaya (martingale mentality). Proper risk management:
ikuti aturan SL, jangan berharap recovery.
CHECK 4: Trend Reversal Detection
ML mendeteksi perubahan tren:
IF ML confidence >= 65% berlawanan dengan posisi:
a) Loss > 40% max DAN profit < -$8
-> TUTUP (reversal + loss signifikan)
b) Akumulasi 3x reversal warning DAN loss < -$10
-> TUTUP (multiple warnings = konfirmasi reversal)
c) Belum memenuhi threshold
-> reversal_warnings += 1 (catat warning)
CHECK 5: Maximum Loss Per Trade
Loss mencapai batas toleransi:
IF loss >= 50% dari max_loss ($25 dari $50):
Exception: golden_time <= 1 jam DAN momentum > -40
-> HOLD (kesempatan terakhir recovery)
Selain itu:
-> TUTUP [S/L] Position loss limit
CHECK 6: Stall Detection
Harga tidak bergerak kemana-mana:
IF 10 candle terakhir range profit < $3
AND current_profit < -$15:
stall_count += 1
IF stall_count >= 5:
-> TUTUP [STALL] Harga stuck, buang waktu & margin
CHECK 7: Daily Loss Limit
Mencegah daily loss limit terlampaui:
potential_daily_loss = daily_loss + abs(min(0, current_profit))
IF potential_daily_loss >= max_daily_loss ($250):
-> TUTUP [LIMIT] Akan melampaui batas harian
CHECK 8: Weekend Close
Proteksi dari gap weekend:
IF hari Jumat setelah 04:00 WIB:
a) profit > 0
-> TUTUP [WEEKEND] Amankan profit
b) profit > -$10
-> TUTUP [WEEKEND] Loss kecil, hindari gap
c) profit <= -$10
-> HOLD (loss terlalu besar untuk cut, evaluasi manual)
CHECK 9: Smart Time-Based Exit (v5: Smarter — Don't Cut Winners)
Mencegah posisi "zombie" TAPI jangan potong posisi profit yang masih tumbuh.
trade_duration = (sekarang - entry_time) dalam jam
profit_growing = momentum > 0
ml_agrees = ML signal searah dengan posisi
IF 4+ jam:
a) profit < $5 DAN NOT profit_growing:
- profit >= $0 -> TUTUP [TIMEOUT] Breakeven + no growth
- profit > -$15 -> TUTUP [TIMEOUT] Small loss + no growth
b) profit >= $5 DAN profit_growing DAN ml_agrees:
-> HOLD (extend time — profit masih tumbuh!)
-> Log: "extending time"
IF 6+ jam:
a) profit < $10 ATAU NOT profit_growing:
-> TUTUP [MAX TIME] (sebelumnya: force close apapun kondisi)
b) profit >= $10 DAN profit_growing:
-> EXTEND ke max 8 jam (v5 BARU — biarkan profit berjalan)
-> Di jam 8+ -> TUTUP [MAX TIME] Take profit
v5 PERUBAHAN:
- 4h: Sekarang cek profit growth, bukan hanya profit < $5
- 6h: BUKAN force close lagi — extend ke 8h jika profitable + growing
- ML agreement dipertimbangkan sebelum timeout
- Prinsip: jangan potong pemenang yang masih berjalan
Visualisasi:
Jam: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
|-----|-----|-----|-----|-----|-----|-----|-----|
entry | | |
| | |
4h check: 6h check: 8h FINAL EXIT
stuck? profitable?
no growth? growing?
-> exit -> extend!
not growing?
-> exit
CHECK 10: Default — HOLD
Tidak ada kondisi exit terpenuhi:
-> HOLD posisi
-> Log status: momentum, TP probability, ML signal
-> Evaluasi ulang di cek berikutnya (~10 detik atau candle baru)
Exit Reason Enum
| Reason | Kode | Deskripsi |
|---|---|---|
TAKE_PROFIT |
take_profit | Target profit tercapai |
TREND_REVERSAL |
trend_reversal | ML deteksi reversal |
DAILY_LIMIT |
daily_limit | Batas harian tercapai |
POSITION_LIMIT |
position_limit | Max loss per trade |
TOTAL_LIMIT |
total_limit | Batas total tercapai |
WEEKEND_CLOSE |
weekend_close | Penutupan Jumat |
TIMEOUT |
timeout | Time-based exit (4h/6h) |
STALL |
stall | Harga stuck |
MANUAL |
manual | Penutupan manual |
Post-Exit Flow
# Setelah posisi ditutup:
# 1. Record hasil trade
risk_result = smart_risk.record_trade_result(profit)
# Update: daily_loss, total_loss, consecutive_losses, mode
# 2. Unregister dari monitoring
smart_risk.unregister_position(ticket)
# 3. Log trade
trade_logger.log_trade_close(
ticket, entry_price, exit_price, profit, pips,
duration, exit_reason, ml_signal, regime, ...
)
# 4. Kirim notifikasi Telegram
await telegram.send_trade_close(trade_info)
# Format: WIN/LOSS/BE, P/L, pips, duration, balance
# 5. Cek limit violations
if risk_result["daily_limit_hit"]:
await send_critical_alert("DAILY LOSS LIMIT")
# Mode -> STOPPED, tidak ada trade lagi hari ini
if risk_result["total_limit_hit"]:
await send_critical_alert("TOTAL LOSS LIMIT")
# Mode -> STOPPED permanen
Diagram Exit Flow
Setiap ~10 detik (atau candle baru), per posisi terbuka:
|
v
Update profit & momentum
|
v
[1] Profit >= $15? ----YES---> Smart TP evaluation
|NO (hard/$40, momentum, peak, prob)
v
[2] Profit $5-$15? ----YES---> Reversal + momentum drop?
|NO -> Early exit
v
[3] Profit < 0? -------YES---> Loss>30% + momentum<-30?
|NO -> EARLY CUT
v
[4] ML Reversal 65%+? -YES---> Loss > 40%? -> TUTUP
|NO Else warning++
v
[5] Loss >= 50% max? --YES---> TUTUP (kecuali golden time)
|NO
v
[6] Stall 10+ candle? -YES---> stall++ -> 5x? TUTUP
|NO
v
[7] Daily limit? ------YES---> TUTUP
|NO
v
[8] Friday close? -----YES---> TUTUP (profit>0 atau loss>-$10)
|NO
v
[9] Time >= 4h? -------YES---> profit<$5? TUTUP
| Time >= 6h? ---YES---> FORCE EXIT
|NO
v
[10] HOLD -> evaluasi ulang 1 detik kemudian